Get the best price!

Music at Amazon

Buy any track at Amazon through this link and Mansized gets 5% of sales. Every order you place helps us build more great stuff for you


Talk / Time off / Chatting / Re: Suicide

< Prev | 1 3 4 5 6 | Next > 

By Ben, Tue 24 Jun at 11:16pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Apple wrote:

Chris wrote:


2. a cry for attention when people actually want to be found and do not really go through with it.



If you don't try it, how can it be an attempt?



I think cries for help are stuff like overdoses, or slashing wrists when they know there is a possibility of bieng found.

When people hang themselves, or jump off bridges in the middle of nowhere they know it is going to be the end...

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Apple, Tue 24 Jun at 11:18pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Gahoo wrote:

Apple wrote:

Why not Gahoo?



Because it should never be accepted in society that it's ok to take you own life. It should be encouraged that you can reach out, get a reality check, there is hope. People can't just go around doing what they like when it effects others, they are not just hurting themselves.



Encouraging to seek help is one thing, but accepting that our life belongs only to ourselves and as such is ultimately ours to do what we choose with is another.

When I tried to kill myself I spoke to a counsellor prior regarding the subject. She pointed out to me that lots of people would miss me and hurt if I killed myself. I thought how utterly selfish of them to leave me in this hell hole of a situation and expect me to have to live. How selfish to force me to have to pull myself out of bed in the morning! It works both ways on the selfish front really.

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Ben, Tue 24 Jun at 11:19pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Apple wrote:

Of course like with any subject there remains the right to object. I just hate that idea people SHOULD have to live.



I cannot honestly believe that I have just read that, on this thread. The subject matter seems to make your comment extremely inappropriate, Apple (and I am saying that in a completely objective way).

If the discussion was a wider one, about the choice to live or die, maybe in cases such as terminal illness, I believe the choice should be there.

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Apple, Tue 24 Jun at 11:20pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

I would suggest the way you kill yourself is a moot point. If you place yourself in a situation where there is a damn good chance you won't make it out alive you are really facing the fact you'll likely die. I guess only exception would be something really manipulative like overdosing when you'd expect someone to walk it any moment or in others company.

I'd suggest anyone who kills themselves wishes that someone would come and rescue them- the fact is they are quite sure that person won't come.

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By ArthurP, Tue 24 Jun at 11:20pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Apple wrote:

ArthurP wrote:


I'd have said it was the exact opposite of having a choice ... being in such a desperate place that you can see no alternative ...



Have you been in the situation?



a chap I worked with hanged himself because his job was (in his opinion) being devalued.

a week before he did it, I was talking to him and he just kept going on about how he could see no way out of the situation he was in and saying he'd rather be dead than let managers walk all over him in the way they were ... no-one thought for a second he actually meant that

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Ben, Tue 24 Jun at 11:21pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Apple wrote:

Gahoo wrote:

Apple wrote:

Why not Gahoo?



Because it should never be accepted in society that it's ok to take you own life. It should be encouraged that you can reach out, get a reality check, there is hope. People can't just go around doing what they like when it effects others, they are not just hurting themselves.



Encouraging to seek help is one thing, but accepting that our life belongs only to ourselves and as such is ultimately ours to do what we choose with is another.

When I tried to kill myself I spoke to a counsellor prior regarding the subject. She pointed out to me that lots of people would miss me and hurt if I killed myself. I thought how utterly selfish of them to leave me in this hell hole of a situation and expect me to have to live. How selfish to force me to have to pull myself out of bed in the morning! It works both ways on the selfish front really.



Is that not Gahoo's point? You identified an issue and got help.

Gahoo suggests that he can't imagine anyone getting to the point where they cannot go/speak to someone/do something that may benefit them, and their state of mind.

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Apple, Tue 24 Jun at 11:21pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

What's inappropriate about it?

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Apple, Tue 24 Jun at 11:22pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Ben wrote:


Gahoo suggests that he can't imagine anyone getting to the point where they cannot go/speak to someone/do something that may benefit them, and their state of mind.



I was pointing out that a 'reality check' isn't usually enough in that situation.

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By STE, Tue 24 Jun at 11:23pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Apple wrote:

Gahoo wrote:

Apple wrote:

Why not Gahoo?



Because it should never be accepted in society that it's ok to take you own life. It should be encouraged that you can reach out, get a reality check, there is hope. People can't just go around doing what they like when it effects others, they are not just hurting themselves.



Encouraging to seek help is one thing, but accepting that our life belongs only to ourselves and as such is ultimately ours to do what we choose with is another.

When I tried to kill myself I spoke to a counsellor prior regarding the subject. She pointed out to me that lots of people would miss me and hurt if I killed myself. I thought how utterly selfish of them to leave me in this hell hole of a situation and expect me to have to live. How selfish to force me to have to pull myself out of bed in the morning! It works both ways on the selfish front really.



I'm sorry you feel that way. Like I said, I can't imagine the thought process behind it all, I've never been in that situation you have. I look at at from the angle that if I was to take my life now, I would be leaving a 2 year old son fatherless, on any level that does not seem right to me.

    ^top

Re: Suicide

By Ben, Tue 24 Jun at 11:26pm 
  • Low quality
      Link to this post

Apple wrote:



I'd suggest anyone who kills themselves wishes that someone would come and rescue them- the fact is they are quite sure that person won't come.



Something we will never know the answer to.....

    ^top


< Prev | 1 3 4 5 6 | Next > 


 

Who's online

500 guests, 5 members including...

Newest readers

ajenkinson  nak  winterlong  

Next birthday

PT_Ant, Tue 25th Nov

128 posts so far, including...

Re: What's your Christmas day menu?

Less than 1 min ago, by Richy23
In Time off / Chatting

Re: Chatting 23/11/2008 - It's windy,
it's raining, but where is the snow?!

3 mins ago, by Richy23
In Time off / Chatting

Re: Mansized Christmas drinkies 12th
December 2008 - venue undecided.

17 mins ago, by beads
In Time off / Travel

Re: Xmas Tipples

17 mins ago, by beads
In Time off / Chatting

Re: Mexo's log

24 mins ago, by Richy23
In Fitness / Training logs

Quantum of Solace verdict

Daniel Craig dumps the quips and ups the action in the meanest Bond outing yet. Read Film editor Chris' review and tell us what you reckon

You're asking...

How are you spending Xmas?

FIFA 09 verdict

EA's latest incarnation shoots and scores

Tasty Tortilla Pizza

Try PJ's latest culinary treat

Fantasy Football latest

We have a new leader ladies and gents

Win a Toshiba laptop!

Plus a fridge full of beer, a Sony PSP and more